Comparing reading devices (including paper),
article.
For the last chapters of the book, I read the paperback. It took barely a paragraph for me to feel frustrated. I kept looking up things on my iPhone, and forgetting to earmark my page.
I have tried most of the devices he tested/compared (most notable exception is the Nook, which I haven't bought because you can't buy books on it outside of the US (!)), and I pretty much follow his perceptions and conclusions.
The Kindle 3 is close to ideal, but a bit slow, can't use web well, and for me the screen is too dark. The iPad 2 is also close to ideal, except a bit on the large/heavy side for just text reading. It's a pity that Apple finds the ereader market as beneath them, they could make a
great one in a 7-inch iPad with Retina Display and a weight under 350 grams.
Let's see what Amazon serves up next. Latest rumors say that their next device will still have an e-ink screen, but it's also color and LCD. This confuses me, so don't ask. Maybe they mean color e-ink and the "LCD" was a mistake. Anyway, color would be nice, but for me contrast is a more pressing issue for the Kindle. So if they use e-ink, I hope it's much improved that way, even though I seem to recall a statement from the manufacturer that we shouldn't expect important upgrades to e-ink in 2011.
Update:
Re the low probability of Apple making a dedicated ereader:
To be fair, one can understand that they want to keep their attention on keeping the iPad and iPhone at no 1, rather than spreading their resources (programmers and engineers) over new, uncertain markets. They are on a
wiiiild ride right now, and small decisions may make a difference between virtually owning the gadget market for the next ten years, or becoming a niche again like with the desktop systems.
Still, I can't help but wish that Apple or at least somebody would make my dream ereader.
Just like I wish Apple or somebody would make my dream portable "typewriter". Like an
Alphasmart Neo, but with a slightly larger screen, more contrast on the screen, and a bit more power and flexibility. The Neo's keyboard is much better than any I've tried on a notebook. (I guess just a cheap notebook might work, only with a deeper and better keyboard.)